• Entrepreneurial Equity
  • Portfolio Investments
    • Current Investments
    • Historic Investments
  • Scribblings
    • Jane Taylor Book Launch
  • Fake News
  • Theology, Religion & Philosophy Corner
    • Does God Exist? The Rational Approach
    • What is the Evidence for Christianity?
    • What did Jesus Actually Teach? Only in His own Words
  • Linkedin
  • Twitter
  • Contact
  • Media Gallery
  • About Me
  • Home
  • Entrepreneurial Equity
  • Portfolio Investments
    • Current Investments
    • Historic Investments
  • Scribblings
    • Jane Taylor Book Launch
  • Fake News
  • Theology, Religion & Philosophy Corner
    • Does God Exist? The Rational Approach
    • What is the Evidence for Christianity?
    • What did Jesus Actually Teach? Only in His own Words

Is it Just to Bomb Libya?

Is it Just to Bomb Libya?

20 Mar 2011
0 Comment
Toby Baxendale
libya

The Prime Minster has justified his leading role in orchestrating a UN resolution to protect the citizens of Libya, particularly those in the east of the country, from the tyrannical oppression of their dictator, Col Gaddafi.  There seems to be an underlying moral urge on the part of our Prime Minster and his Deputy to stop the blatant outrage that is taking place just south of the Mediterranean. I sympathise.

Historically, we must also remember that Gaddafi part funded the war of aggression by the Irish Republican Army in Northern Ireland and in the mainland of Great Britain itself, and in some of our overseas territories, killing 3,000 civilians in the period known as the “Troubles”. Responsibility for the Lockerbie bombing also sits squarely at his feet. He is clearly a vile and demented individual who is capable of inflicting pain and destruction on not only his people, but those of many other nations. I will open a bottle of champagne upon the announcement of his death, and that of any of his henchmen associated with so much pain and destruction.

There are many murderous tyrants around the world, and plenty of morally indefensible states, but we are not on a crusade to bomb them all and liberate their people. The communist government in China unleashed untold brutality against their own people, notably in the Tiananmen Square uprisings in 1989. Despite moves toward capitalism, the Chinese people continue to be oppressed. Are we seeking to bomb them? Surely not. They have a population over a billion, and a standing army of over 2 million. Best leave them alone! More recently, in Sri Lanka, 20,000 Tamils were killed in May 2009. And what about the on-going treatment of the people of Zimbabwe? Here we have another tyrant-led country that has prosecuted a war of famine and pestilence against his own people. I am sure you get the picture.

I submit that our leadership shows a selective application of morals. Cameron is very much in the neo-Conservative tradition here.  I feel it would be better for him to be honest and practical, and simply say “with the support of the international community, we have an opportunity to depose a tyrant with a history of aggression towards the UK, with hopefully low costs to ourselves, amidst the chaos of a domestic rebellion”.

You either apply your moral standard universally, or it lacks validity. Why are we not bombing Bahrain? I wouldn’t advocate it, but Cameron should, if he is to be consistent.

Meanwhile, our Deputy Prime Minister, Nick Clegg, leader of the Liberal Democratic Party, says he has voiced his support for possible military intervention in Libya, saying that any action would be carried out in order to “uphold international law.”

So Clegg appeals to a higher moral sanction called International Law. This is where the nations of the world, some with very dubious track records, decide what we all should do. I wonder if the UN had passed resolutions saying Northern Ireland should be ceded with immediate effect to the Republic of Ireland against the wishes of the vast majority of the population of both parts of the island, he would unquestionably seek to obey this command from on high. That is hypothetical, but there have in fact been many resolutions against Israel. Should we be as vigorous in enforcing these as we are being with the latest resolution against Libya? I do not think Clegg would go that far.

Clegg is not a true Liberal. The great 19th century Liberals such as Cobden and Bright would have recommended arbitration and free trade for breaking down barriers and opening up countries. That should be the long term policy of all nations interested in freedom. The interdependence that results from global trade provides strong motivation for peace. There is no need for international law or global government.

For the short term, the moral yardstick a liberal must apply is to treat international relations as they treat interpersonal relations: to live and let live, and only use force in response to aggression. Now, Libya certainly has aggressed against us over the years, and a liberal could have supported the bombings of Libya undertaken by the USA with the support of the UK under the Thatcher government in April of 1986. What aggression have they dealt out to us today?

The deputy prime minister, whose Liberal Democrat Party opposed the war in Iraq, said: “this is not Iraq. We are not going to war”. Such cowardice, to hide behind semantics! If bombing the hell out of Libyan air defences, and shooting at tanks and other armoured units is not warfare, I do not know what is. In truth, I do not think Clegg has the stomach for this, and he’s trying to post-rationalise it with appeals to a higher moral authority, and to black out from his mind the uncomfortable reality that he is party to an act of aggression against another state. Bless his Liberal heart and soul; it is all too much for him. More than ever, he must be wondering whether he really wants to be in this Coalition?

Faced with overwhelming western air power, Gaddafi may well resort to guerilla warfare, and send his men into cities for protracted battles, street by street, house by house. The misery that this would inflict upon those cities has not been experienced in Western Europe since WWII.

I see no justification for this war.

However as it has started, I hope this act of aggression by the UK and its allies is swift and decisive. Having committed to intervention, I hope our fighting men have freedom of action to finish this conflict quickly as possible. Failing this, I hope we are brave enough to extract ourselves very quickly, if it turns out that the rebellion does not have the strength to overthrow the regime.

My thoughts are now with all the people involved in this conflict, and I pray for peace.

About the Author
“Toby Baxendale is an entrepreneur who built up, amongst other things, the UK's largest fresh fish supplier to the Food Service sector, see www.directseafoods.co.uk, and recently sold it. Toby is dedicated to furthering the teaching of the Austrian school of economics. He established and funded the 1st Distinguished Hayek Visiting Teaching Fellowship Program at the LSE in Honour of the Nobel Laureate F A Hayek. Toby is Chairman of The Cobden Centre. Richard Cobden's timeless principles of the abolition of legal privilege of the few at the expense of the many are worthy in this day and age to promote.

Social Share

  • google-share

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

*
*

More Scribblings

Japan, an Opportunity Awaits Us

11 Jun 2020

Austrian Economics Podcast

22 Oct 2019

Economics for the Many

18 Oct 2018

What is Right Wing?

06 Nov 2017

The Protectionist Zombie Is Back

19 Jul 2017

Brexit Podcast

16 Jun 2017

Liberty Me

20 Dec 2013

My Time for Speakers for Schools

07 Dec 2013

The Selfish Gene, its Extended Phenotypic Effects and Human Cooperation

19 Aug 2013

In Defense of the Euro (An Austrian Perspective)

15 Aug 2013

IM70.3 Mallorca - The Chairman's report

13 May 2013

AEP and “The Chicago Plan Revisited

18 Jan 2013

Ron Paul’s Monetary Policy Anthology

08 Jan 2013

Exorcising the Ghost of Ironman Zurich

14 Nov 2012

Communist Approval For Western Central Banking

28 Sep 2012

The Motive Powers Of Destructionism

19 Sep 2012

The Hope Of Osborne And The Error Of Osborne

14 Sep 2012

The Ultimate Subsidy For The Rich

03 Sep 2012

Gross And Net Product

30 Aug 2012

Did The Savings Glut Or Massive Monetary Epansion Cause The Boom And The Bust?

13 Aug 2012

Forward To Liberalism

29 Jul 2012

Hugh Hendry v. Joseph Stiglitz

18 Jul 2012

Fraud - Documentary

13 Jul 2012

A Great Teacher

13 Jul 2012

Fraud

13 Jul 2012

Our Central Bankers Are intellectually Bankrupt

09 May 2012

Tag Cloud

ABCT Austrian School Bank of England Banking Benjamin M. Anderson Economics F A Hayek Federal Reserve Fractional Reserve Banking Fraud gold Hayek Lecture 2010 Henry Hazlitt Honest Money Huerta de Soto inflation Insight Jean Baptiste Say Keynes Keynesianism MIses Monetarism Quantitative Easing Richard Cobden Sean Corrigan
Creative Commons License
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NoDerivs 3.0 Unported License.
Proudly built by Lemongrass Media - Web Design Hertfordshire